Our Story

In November 1949, the church acquired its first building—a 2½-family house at 91 North 7th Street. The sanctuary began in the pastor’s living room and expanded as attendance grew. By 1953, membership reached 24, and by 1959, it had grown to 63.

Despite limited financial resources (only 17 regular incomes), the church raised over $11,000 annually by 1959. Pastor Willcox earned $65 per week, and the church supported Assistant Pastor Richard F. Lovelace, later of Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary.

By 1955, the need for a larger space became clear. A building fund was launched in 1957–58. On September 11, 1962, the Board of Elders held their first prayer day, adopting the theme “Missionaries to Newark.” This marked a shift in identity—from a social religious group to a mission station in the city.

God’s provision came through the Open Air Campaigners (OAC), led by Rev. Arthur Williams. Their presence strengthened CGC’s evangelistic efforts. Eventually, the church was offered the building at 17 Lyons Avenue by the Elizabeth Avenue Baptist Church. After months of prayer and negotiation, CGC moved into its new home on February 29, 1964.

With a dedicated church building, CGC flourished. Evangelistic seminars, youth outreach through the Conqueror’s Gospel Team, and various ministries expanded the church’s impact.

The 1967 Newark riots, though tragic, opened hearts to the Gospel. CGC seized the opportunity for summer evangelism and deepened its commitment to youth ministry. By the late 1960s and early 1970s, teens were the heartbeat of the church, with Friday night Conqueror’s meetings drawing over 100 attendees.

This vibrant youth ministry led to the construction of an education wing and the founding of Calvary Christian School in the 1970s.

In the early 1980s, the Willcoxes sensed it was time to transition leadership. Though initially planning to step down, they remained at the congregation’s request. Their calling to missions led them to Uganda for short-term service in 1989–91. On November 17, 1992, they departed for full-time missionary work under the Anglican Church of Uganda.

Though CGC lost its founding pastor of 45 years, the Good Shepherd continued to guide His church.

Following the Willcoxes’ departure, the Board of Elders led the church. After a year of prayer and discernment, Rev. Dr. Steven B. Davis—who had grown up in CGC and previously served as Youth Minister—was called as Pastor on June 6, 1993.

Rev. Davis and his wife Denise had led the Conqueror’s Club before serving in Virginia. Their return marked a full-circle moment for CGC.